ENGINEER AND INVENTOR  |  April 1893

Development in Steel Making

1890s steelworks with electrical power lines
Modern recreation in 1890s lithograph style

The London Times gives a long account of a number of experiments lately made with a new description of steel, the success of which appears to point to a revolution in the steel trade. An important advance in the manufacture of what is technically known as tool steel, it says, has recently been developed into practical shape in England. It is a new process, the invention of Mr. Francis G. Bates, of Philadelphia, which has been under trial in this country for the past twelve months on a working scale. It consists in converting a low-grade steel by a remarkable economical process into a high-class steel, suitable for making turning tools for iron and steel, punches, chisels and similar articles.

The system is carried out by placing bars of Bessemer or other steel, containing a low percentage of carbon, in a specially designed furnace and subjecting them to a high temperature. The steel to be converted is embedded in a carbonaceous compound of special character, and placed in a chamber in a furnace, which has three fire grates, with flues and passages so constructed that a surprising economy of fuel is secured by reason of the perfect character of the combustion. So complete is the combustion that there is no escape of any visible products in the form of smoke after the furnace has been started, and although a very high temperature is maintained, equal to melting cast iron, the temperature of the escaping gases is remarkably low, so thoroughly is every atom of heat utilized.

An important advance in the manufacture of what is technically known as tool steel, it says, has recently been developed into practical shape in England.

Many tons of steel have been so converted and a number of tools have been made from it. In all cases the tools thus made have turned out exceedingly well, some of them doing work comparable with Mushet steel, which is the most costly steel made. Various brands of low-grade steel, including Bessemer, Glengarnock, basic, Brown, Bayley and Brymbo steel, costing on the average £7 per ton, have been tried. From these bars, when converted, turning tools, punches and chisels were made and successfully tested in actual work. The process is, in fact, a commercial success, and constitutes a new departure in the manufacture of high-class steel from steel of a low grade.

Many well-known users of steel have, after due trial, certified to its value, and have expressed their readiness to adopt it. Should the apparently reasonable expectations entertained, respecting this steel be realized, a revolution in the steel trade should practically result. Moreover, by the Bates system, not only can steel be successfully treated, but wrought and cast iron can be converted. Its application, in fact, appears to be very far reaching and capable of meeting the requirements of war as well as those of peace.

Curator's Review

This article captures a confident moment in late nineteenth century industry. Steel was no longer only forged by skill and habit. It was being studied, measured, and improved with intention. The report focuses on a process that converts low grade steel into high class tool steel. That promise alone would have attracted serious attention in workshops across Britain.

What interests me most is the emphasis on economy and control. The furnace design is described with pride. Fuel use is efficient. Heat is fully utilised. Smoke is absent. These details reveal more than technical progress. They show an industry learning discipline. The language carries optimism. It suggests belief in transformation. This is industrial ambition recorded in real time.

Victorian metallurgy print background and antique steelmaking books plus a Browse books call to action button.
eBay (US) advertisement — search the global marketplace for antique metallurgy books

Glossary

Tool Steel
A high-quality steel designed for cutting, shaping or forming other materials. It must retain hardness and strength under repeated mechanical stress.
Bessemer Steel
Steel produced using the Bessemer process, which removes impurities from molten iron by blowing air through it. It allowed large-scale, economical steel production in the nineteenth century.
Carbonaceous Compound
A material rich in carbon used in the conversion process. In this article it surrounds the steel bars to increase their carbon content during heating.
Mushet Steel
A high-performance tool steel developed in the nineteenth century by Robert Forester Mushet. It was known for exceptional hardness and was considered costly.
Wrought Iron
A form of iron with very low carbon content. It is tough and malleable but not as hard as tool steel.
Combustion Efficiency
The degree to which fuel is fully burned and heat is utilised. The article highlights the furnace design as achieving complete combustion with minimal waste.

Frequently asked questions

What problem in steel manufacturing was the Bates process attempting to solve?

It aimed to economically convert low-grade, low-carbon steel into high-class tool steel suitable for turning tools, punches, chisels and similar workshop uses.

How did the Bates system convert low grade steel into tool steel?

Bars of Bessemer or other low-carbon steel were placed in a specially designed furnace, embedded in a carbonaceous compound, and heated to a very high temperature so the material was converted into higher-grade tool steel.

How did the converted steel compare with Mushet steel?

Tools made from the converted steel reportedly performed exceedingly well, with some doing work comparable with Mushet steel, described as the most costly steel made.

Why did contemporaries believe this process could revolutionise the steel trade?

Because it was presented as a commercial success that could produce high-class steel from cheaper low-grade steel, gained support from experienced users, and was claimed to extend beyond steel to wrought and cast iron for wide-ranging applications.

Editorial Policy

This article is a heritage reprint from its original publication and is presented as a historical record. Phillaneum seeks to preserve such material in both human- and machine-readable form, with minor adjustments to format, layout, and typography made to improve clarity and accessibility for modern readers.

In some cases, original illustrations have been carefully re-rendered using contemporary tools to improve legibility on modern displays. Where this has occurred, the imagery remains faithful to the source material in composition and detail, and is intended as a visual facsimile rather than a reinterpretation of the historical artefact.

Editorial commentary and contextual material are provided separately by Phillaneum curators to support historical understanding and do not alter the original source text. This article is presented for cultural and historical interest; statements within reflect the period in which they were written and should be understood within that historical context rather than as contemporary guidance or opinion.

Change log

  1. [2021-01-01] Web publication
  2. [2021-05-12] Minor update
  3. [2021-12-14] Bulk general update
  4. [2022-06-19] Minor editorial adjustments
  5. [2026-02-19] Migrated to Chronos Engine